Discover the Top 6 Rums Perfect for Piña Coladas

Rate this post

Who doesn’t love a refreshing piña colada on a warm, sunny day? This iconic tropical cocktail, with its blend of rum, pineapple juice, and creamy coconut, is a delightful treat for any occasion. However, choosing the right rum can make all the difference in crafting the perfect piña colada experience. In this guide, we’ll explore six of the best rums that are ideal for making this classic cocktail shine.

Why Choosing the Right Rum Matters?

Before we delve into our top picks, let’s briefly discuss why selecting the right rum is essential for creating a delicious piña colada. Rum serves as the foundation of this cocktail, providing the base spirit that complements the fruity and creamy elements. Different types of rum can offer unique flavor profiles, ranging from light and crisp to rich and complex. By choosing a rum that harmonizes with the other ingredients, you can elevate the overall taste and enjoyment of your piña colada.

Factors to Consider

When selecting rums for piña coladas, several factors come into play. Here are some key considerations to keep in mind:

Flavor Profile

  • Light and Crisp: Rums with a light and crisp profile are often preferred for piña coladas, as they allow the tropical flavors to shine through without overpowering the drink.
  • Coconut or Pineapple Notes: Flavored rums infused with coconut or pineapple can enhance the cocktail’s tropical essence, adding depth and complexity to the flavor profile.
  • Balance: Look for rums that strike a balance between sweetness and acidity, ensuring a harmonious blend with the other ingredients in the piña colada.

Quality and Reputation

  • Reputable Brands: Opt for rums from well-known and respected distilleries with a track record of producing high-quality spirits.
  • Reviews and Ratings: Consider rums that have received positive reviews and high ratings from experts and enthusiasts, indicating their superior taste and craftsmanship.

Price and Accessibility

  • Value for Money: While price is not always indicative of quality, it’s essential to find a rum that offers good value for its price point.
  • Availability: Choose rums that are readily available in your region to ensure accessibility for future purchases.

The Top 6 Rums for Piña Coladas

Now that we’ve covered the basics, let’s dive into our selection of the top six rums perfect for piña coladas:

Plantation Isle of Fiji Rum

Plantation Rum Isle Of Fiji Packaging Design

  • Rating: 95 Points (Wine Enthusiast)
  • Flavor Profile: Aroma of banana bread with hints of pineapple, followed by juicy grilled pineapple on the palate with notes of vanilla, coconut, and cinnamon.
  • Price: $28 (Total Wine & More)

Plantation Isle of Fiji Rum is a premium rum that epitomizes the exotic flavors and tropical allure of the Fiji islands. Crafted by Maison Ferrand, a renowned French spirits producer, this rum is a blend of tradition, innovation, and the unique terroir of Fiji.

  • Flavor Profile: The aroma of Plantation Isle of Fiji Rum tantalizes the senses with notes of ripe banana bread drizzled with honey, accompanied by a subtle hint of pineapple. On the palate, the rum bursts with flavors of juicy grilled pineapple, complemented by nuances of vanilla, coconut, and cinnamon. The result is a harmonious blend of tropical sweetness and spice, reminiscent of a sun-kissed paradise.
  • Aging Process: Plantation Isle of Fiji Rum undergoes a meticulous aging process that contributes to its exceptional flavor profile. Initially distilled and aged for two to three years in Fiji, the rum is then transported to France, where it undergoes further aging in ex-Ferrand Cognac casks. This unique aging regimen imparts depth, complexity, and refinement to the final product, elevating it to a level of unparalleled quality.
  • Accolades: Plantation Isle of Fiji Rum has received widespread acclaim from critics and enthusiasts alike, earning an impressive rating of 95 points from Wine Enthusiast. Additionally, it was recognized as one of the Top 100 Spirits of 2020, further solidifying its reputation as a standout rum in the global spirits landscape.
  • Versatility: While Plantation Isle of Fiji Rum shines when enjoyed neat or on the rocks, its exceptional flavor profile also makes it a perfect choice for mixing in cocktails. Whether used in classic recipes like piña coladas and daiquiris or innovative creations, this rum adds a touch of tropical sophistication to any libation.
  • Exotic Origins: The Fiji islands, renowned for their pristine beaches, lush rainforests, and warm hospitality, serve as the backdrop for the creation of Plantation Isle of Fiji Rum. By harnessing the natural bounty and cultural heritage of Fiji, Maison Ferrand has crafted a rum that embodies the spirit of the islands and invites drinkers on a journey of exploration and discovery.
  • Availability: While availability may vary depending on your location, Plantation Isle of Fiji Rum can often be found in well-stocked liquor stores and specialty spirits retailers. Its growing popularity and esteemed reputation ensure that enthusiasts can savor the taste of Fiji wherever they are in the world.

With its rich flavor, exceptional craftsmanship, and exotic origins, Plantation Isle of Fiji Rum offers a sensory journey to the tropical paradise of Fiji with every sip. Whether enjoyed straight, mixed in cocktails, or savored as a special treat, this rum is sure to delight discerning palates and evoke the essence of island living.

Monkey Rum with Toasted Coconut

Just Malt: Zane Lamprey's New Monkey Rum - A First Sampling

  • Rating: 89 Points (Wine Enthusiast)
  • Flavor Profile: Coconut scent with hints of vanilla, followed by a sweet and slightly bitter palate, finishing brisk with vanilla notes.
  • Price: $26 (Total Wine & More)

Monkey Rum with Toasted Coconut is a unique and flavorful offering from the Monkey Rum brand, backed by TV host Zane Lamprey. This rum is distinguished by its infusion of toasted coconut, which adds a rich and aromatic dimension to the spirit.

  • Flavor Profile: The aroma of Monkey Rum with Toasted Coconut is redolent with the sweet and nutty scent of coconut, enhanced by subtle hints of vanilla. On the palate, the rum delivers a delightful interplay of flavors, with the sweetness of coconut balanced by a faint bitterness and notes of vanilla. The finish is brisk and marked by a lingering warmth, leaving a satisfying aftertaste.
  • Aging Process: Monkey Rum with Toasted Coconut is made from a blend of rums aged for six months to one year, allowing the flavors to meld and mature over time. The addition of toasted coconut during the aging process infuses the rum with a distinctively tropical character, creating a harmonious fusion of flavors.
  • Brand Endorsement: The Monkey Rum brand, founded by TV personality Zane Lamprey, has gained a loyal following among rum enthusiasts for its innovative approach to crafting spirits. Lamprey’s passion for travel and adventure is reflected in the brand’s ethos, which celebrates exploration, discovery, and the pursuit of new experiences.
  • Versatility: While Monkey Rum with Toasted Coconut can certainly be enjoyed on its own, it truly shines when used in cocktails. Its rich coconut flavor and smooth texture make it a perfect choice for classic tropical drinks like piña coladas, as well as creative concoctions that call for a touch of island-inspired indulgence.
  • Accessibility: Monkey Rum with Toasted Coconut is widely available at select liquor stores and online retailers, making it easily accessible to consumers seeking a premium rum with a distinctive flavor profile. Its affordable price point and versatile nature make it a popular choice for both casual drinkers and seasoned mixologists alike.

With its enticing aroma, flavorful profile, and association with the adventurous spirit of Zane Lamprey, Monkey Rum with Toasted Coconut offers a delightful drinking experience that transports the palate to sun-drenched shores and tropical retreats. Whether enjoyed straight, on the rocks, or in cocktails, this rum is sure to captivate the senses and inspire moments of joy and relaxation.

Sugar Island Coconut Rum

Sugar Island Coconut Rum | Quality Liquor Store

  • Rating: 88 Points (Wine Enthusiast)
  • Flavor Profile: Clear with a pronounced coconut aroma and flavor reminiscent of suntan lotion, sweet but not cloying.
  • Price: $19 (Total Wine & More)

Sugar Island Coconut Rum is a delectable coconut-flavored rum crafted with precision and care by Sugar Island Rum Company. This rum captures the essence of the Caribbean with its smooth and sweet coconut flavor, making it a favorite among rum enthusiasts and cocktail aficionados alike.

  • Flavor Profile: From the moment you uncork a bottle of Sugar Island Coconut Rum, you’ll be greeted by the irresistible aroma of fresh coconut. Upon tasting, the rum delights the palate with its luscious coconut flavor, reminiscent of sun-kissed beaches and tropical breezes. Unlike some overly sweet coconut rums, Sugar Island strikes the perfect balance, offering a hint of sweetness without overwhelming the senses.
  • Sourcing and Production: Sugar Island Coconut Rum is made with rum sourced from the West Indies and Barbados, two regions renowned for their superior sugarcane and rum-making traditions. The rum is carefully blended and bottled in California, where it undergoes a meticulous process to infuse it with the natural essence of coconut. The result is a high-quality rum that embodies the spirit of the Caribbean.
  • Versatility: While Sugar Island Coconut Rum is a delight to sip on its own, it truly shines when used in cocktails. Its rich coconut flavor adds depth and complexity to classic tropical drinks like piña coladas, daiquiris, and rum punches. Additionally, it can be used to create innovative cocktails that celebrate the flavors of the Caribbean and transport drinkers to exotic destinations with each sip.
  • Appearance: In the glass, Sugar Island Coconut Rum presents a clear and inviting appearance, inviting you to indulge in its tropical allure. Its smooth and velvety texture coats the palate, leaving a lingering sweetness that beckons for another sip.
  • Accessibility: Sugar Island Coconut Rum is widely available at liquor stores, online retailers, and bars across the United States. Its popularity continues to grow as more people discover its delightful flavor and versatility in cocktails.

With its authentic coconut flavor, impeccable quality, and versatility in mixology, Sugar Island Coconut Rum offers a taste of the Caribbean that can be enjoyed anytime, anywhere. Whether sipped neat, mixed in cocktails, or used to add a tropical twist to your favorite recipes, this rum is sure to transport you to paradise with every sip.

Brinley Gold Shipwreck Coconut Rum

Product Review: Brinley Gold Shipwreck Rum – The Hungry Historian

Brinley Gold Shipwreck Coconut Rum is a premium coconut-flavored rum known for its exceptional quality and taste. Produced by Brinley Gold Rum Distillery, located on the picturesque island of St. Kitts in the Caribbean, this rum is crafted with meticulous attention to detail and a commitment to excellence.

  • Flavor Profile: Brinley Gold Shipwreck Coconut Rum offers a rich and indulgent flavor profile characterized by the unmistakable essence of coconut. With each sip, you’ll experience the smooth and creamy texture of coconut, accompanied by subtle hints of tropical fruit and caramelized sugar. The rum strikes a perfect balance between sweetness and complexity, making it an ideal choice for crafting delicious piña coladas and other tropical cocktails.
  • Quality and Craftsmanship: Brinley Gold Rum Distillery takes pride in using only the finest ingredients and traditional distillation methods to create their premium rums. The coconut flavor is carefully infused into the rum using natural ingredients, resulting in an authentic and flavorful spirit that captures the essence of the Caribbean.
  • Awards and Recognition: Brinley Gold Shipwreck Coconut Rum has garnered numerous awards and accolades for its outstanding quality and taste. With its smooth and flavorful profile, it has earned the admiration of rum enthusiasts and critics alike, solidifying its reputation as one of the top coconut rums on the market.
  • Versatility: In addition to being an excellent choice for piña coladas, Brinley Gold Shipwreck Coconut Rum can be enjoyed in a variety of cocktail recipes or simply sipped neat over ice. Its versatile nature makes it a staple in any rum lover’s collection, offering endless possibilities for creative mixology.
  • Availability and Accessibility: While availability may vary depending on your location, Brinley Gold Shipwreck Coconut Rum is widely distributed in many markets, making it accessible to rum enthusiasts around the world. Whether you’re enjoying a tropical getaway or hosting a cocktail party at home, this exceptional rum is sure to impress with its superior taste and quality craftsmanship.

Crusoe Organic Rum

Piña Colada Cocktail Recipe | Cruzan®

Crusoe Organic Rum stands out as a premium choice for those seeking high-quality, organic rum with a commitment to sustainability. Crafted with care and precision, this rum embodies the essence of organic farming practices and artisanal distillation techniques.

  • Flavor Profile: Crusoe Organic Rum offers a unique flavor profile that reflects its organic origins. With each sip, you’ll discover nuanced notes of sugarcane, vanilla, and oak, layered with hints of tropical fruit and spices. The rum’s smooth and velvety texture enhances the drinking experience, leaving a lingering warmth on the palate.
  • Organic Certification: What sets Crusoe Organic Rum apart is its organic certification, which guarantees that the rum is produced using only organic ingredients and methods. From the sugarcane fields to the distillery, every step of the production process adheres to strict organic standards, ensuring purity and sustainability.
  • Sustainable Practices: In addition to being certified organic, Crusoe Organic Rum is committed to sustainable practices that minimize environmental impact. The distillery employs renewable energy sources, such as solar power and biomass, to reduce carbon emissions and conserve natural resources. Furthermore, waste management and recycling initiatives are implemented to minimize waste and promote eco-friendly production methods.
  • Artisanal Distillation: Crusoe Organic Rum is meticulously crafted using traditional artisanal distillation techniques, allowing the natural flavors and aromas of the sugarcane to shine through. Small-batch production ensures quality control and attention to detail, resulting in a rum of unparalleled smoothness and complexity.
  • Versatility: Whether enjoyed neat, on the rocks, or as the base spirit in cocktails like piña coladas, Crusoe Organic Rum offers versatility and depth of flavor. Its organic and sustainable credentials make it a conscious choice for environmentally-conscious consumers who value quality and authenticity.
  • Availability: While availability may vary depending on your location, Crusoe Organic Rum can often be found in specialty liquor stores, organic markets, and online retailers. Its growing popularity among discerning rum enthusiasts has led to wider distribution, making it more accessible to consumers seeking premium organic spirits.

Crusoe Organic Rum represents the pinnacle of organic rum production, combining exceptional quality with a commitment to sustainability. From its flavorful profile to its eco-friendly ethos, this rum embodies the spirit of conscious consumption and artisanal craftsmanship. Whether enjoyed on its own or mixed into cocktails, Crusoe Organic Rum promises a truly satisfying drinking experience for discerning rum aficionados.

Doorly’s Macaw White Rum

Piña Colada Cocktail Recipe - SelvaRey Rum

Doorly’s Macaw White Rum is a premium white rum that hails from the renowned Foursquare Distillery in Barbados. Named after the colorful macaw birds native to the Caribbean, this rum embodies the vibrant spirit and rich heritage of the region.

  • Flavor Profile: Doorly’s Macaw White Rum boasts a clean and crisp flavor profile, characterized by subtle notes of sugarcane, citrus, and tropical fruits. Its smooth and refreshing taste makes it a versatile choice for cocktails, including classic favorites like piña coladas.
  • Distillation Process: Distilled using traditional copper pot stills, Doorly’s Macaw White Rum undergoes a meticulous distillation process that ensures purity and clarity. The rum is carefully crafted to preserve the natural flavors and aromas of the sugarcane, resulting in a smooth and well-balanced spirit.
  • Authenticity: As a product of the Foursquare Distillery, Doorly’s Macaw White Rum embodies the authenticity and craftsmanship for which Barbadian rum is renowned. With over a century of experience in rum production, Foursquare Distillery upholds the highest standards of quality and tradition, delivering rums that are celebrated by connoisseurs worldwide.
  • Versatility: Doorly’s Macaw White Rum is a versatile spirit that can be enjoyed in a variety of cocktails, from classic daiquiris to refreshing mojitos. Its light and airy profile make it an excellent choice for mixing, allowing the flavors of other ingredients to shine through while providing a solid foundation of rum character.
  • Cocktail Pairings: In addition to being a key ingredient in piña coladas, Doorly’s Macaw White Rum pairs well with a range of tropical and citrus-based cocktails. Its clean and crisp profile complements the bright flavors of pineapple, coconut, and lime, making it a go-to choice for creating refreshing drinks that evoke the spirit of the Caribbean.
  • Availability: Doorly’s Macaw White Rum is widely available in liquor stores and online retailers, making it easily accessible to rum enthusiasts seeking a premium white rum for their home bar. Its affordability and versatility make it a popular choice for both amateur mixologists and seasoned bartenders alike.

With its clean flavor, authentic heritage, and versatility in cocktails, Doorly’s Macaw White Rum is a standout option for rum lovers seeking a high-quality white rum for their favorite drinks. Whether enjoyed in a classic piña colada or mixed into inventive tropical concoctions, this rum promises a delightful drinking experience that captures the essence of the Caribbean.


In conclusion, selecting the right rum is crucial for creating the perfect piña colada experience. Whether you prefer a light and crisp rum or one infused with coconut or pineapple flavors, there are plenty of options to suit your taste preferences. By considering factors such as flavor profile, quality, and price, you can find the ideal rum to elevate your piña colada game. So go ahead, stock up on your favorite rum, blend up some tropical goodness, and transport yourself to paradise with every sip of your homemade piña colada.